A spat over the re-appointment of a judge to a European court has given rise to accusations of politicians meddling with the judiciary. The country in question? Norway.
The controversy stems from Oslo’s decision to shorten the mandate of a Norwegian judge sitting on the European Free Trade Area (EFTA) court.
Senior judges and academics in Norway have accused the government of undermining the court, saying it sets a bad example to authoritarian regimes across Europe. Critics suspect the move is intended as a way of replacing the judge with someone more explicitly pro-Norwegian, after local press reports that the government is upset after a string of court losses.
The Norwegian judge in question is Per Christiansen, whose six-year term was due to end in January. After failing to find a replacement, the Norwegian government reappointed him last month — but only for three years, rather than the usual six.
Norway’s government — a mix of conservatives and populists — says Christiansen should retire when he turns 70, as is required of all judges working in Norway. Critics point out that EFTA’s own rules do not include an age-limit.
The Norwegian Judges Association said the government’s decision was “very unfortunate,” risked undermining the court’s legitimacy and could feed “speculation about whether there might in fact be other reasons for reducing the term of office.”
“We find ourselves in a situation where the governments of several countries, including in Europe, are endeavoring to undermine the independence of the courts by changing their composition through various formal means,” wrote Ingjerd Thune, a district court judge who heads the association, and Henrik Bull, a supreme court judge. “We fear, however, that what has happened in connection with the reappointment of Judge Christiansen could undermine Norway’s credibility” when trying to counter such meddling.
Ane Haavardsdatter Lunde, a spokesperson for the Norwegian Ministry of Foreign Affairs, said it would respond to the judges who have voiced concerns but declined to comment further.
Iceland, Liechtenstein and Norway are members of the EFTA Court, each with one permanent judge on the court which oversees the countries’ access to the EU single market and rules on their application of EU laws.
Press reports describe the Norwegian government as increasingly critical of the three-judge EFTA Court following a string of losses. There is a perception that the court is stricter than the European Court of Justice, to the detriment of Norway.
In recent years the court has ruled that Norway breached European law by restricting the ability of foreign construction companies to operate or failing to clean up air pollution. Another recent judgment held Norway should have done more to clamp down on money laundering and terrorism financing.
A question of independence
The Surveillance Authority — which, like the European Commission, is responsible for enforcing EFTA rules — is investigating the appointment.
“Any question mark raised concerning the independence of an EEA Institution is a very serious matter, and that makes it all the more important that we give the states a chance to make their point of view known before drawing our own conclusions,” said Carsten Zatschler, legal and executive director at the EFTA Surveillance Authority.
The probe follows a complaint by Norwegian academics, including Mads Andenæs, a United Nations special rapporteur, who also reportedly applied for the position. They give several examples of Norwegian judges who have worked at international courts beyond the age of 70.
“Current European affairs and recent Norwegian history should make the authorities particularly sensitive not to appear to manipulate retirement ages for judges,” according to the academics.
The move was reminiscent of 1940 when “Norwegian supreme court judges resigned when lower retirement limits opened [the way to pack] the court with collaborators.”
The issue has also landed on the desk of the EFTA Court. In a separate procedure, a Lichtenstein court has asked the court to clarify whether the abnormal mandate could result in its rulings being declared invalid.
(politico)
Norway is taking a nose dive into the digital world — at least with radio. The Norwegian government will be the first country to completely transition to digital radio, and it’ll start when it switches off FM radio channels on January 11, at exactly at 11:11:11 AM local time.
Oman minister of Commerce and Industry received Borge Brende, Minister of Foreign Affairs in Norway, yesterday.
IB World Schools from across the Barents region are working to help create sustainable future societies
Marina Kruptsova, a Gimnazia 9 school student, enjoyed visiting Senja Videregående school, and sharing her culture. She says: “Almost every evening we spent time with Norwegian students. On the first day we presented national costumes, and we taught the Norwegians how to play Russian games, which was great fun. On other days, they taught us how to play their games.”
The Church of Norway—a Lutheran body—ceased to be Norway’s official “public religion” on January 1, and its ministers are no longer government employees.
Government’s believes in ‘dialogue and cooperation to create mutual trust’ as solution to ending conflict
Celebrations have begun as people around the world ring in the New Year.
Norway’s public broadcaster apologized for referencing Nazi death camps and the Jewish genocide in a satirical cartoon about the financial situation of university students.
India and Norway will soon begin collaborative research in the area of antimicrobial resistance. The broad research areas covered under this collaborative research programme include, surveillance systems for antimicrobial resistance and antibiotic use in humans and/or animal population; design, implementation and evaluation of antibiotic stewardship programmes including intervention studies to promote infection control and clinical practice guidelines in hospitals, primary care and veterinary medicine; novel strategies for diagnosis and treatment of infections caused by multidrug resistance bacteria; and ecological, evolutionary and molecular properties of antimicrobial resistance.
Norway has substantially increased its assistance for the Syrian crisis in 2016. ‘The war in Syria is affecting millions of people and has ramifications for the whole world. Norway has been at the forefront of efforts to mobilise more international aid, and we have provided NOK 2.7 billion ourselves this year. This funding is helping to save lives and provide schooling for children and young people in a crisis situation,’ said Minister of Foreign Affairs Børge Brende.
As directed by the Prime Minister, Sri Lanka Fisheries and Aquatic Resources Development Ministry through the Ministry of Foreign Affairs has requested the Government of Norway for technical assistance for formulation of a National Fisheries and Aquaculture Policy.
Two Polish men accused of blowing up ATMs in Germany, Denmark, Norway and Sweden have been detained by police in Poland.
At a corner table of the Marriott Hotel in Pakistan’s capital, an emissary from the Taliban’s supreme leader arrived with a message of peace.
It is understandable that the image of NATO in Serbia is not good, says Norwegian Ambassador to Serbia Arne Bjornstad.
Norwegian oil companies have scaled back their 2017 investment plans, according to the latest Statistics Norway survey.
Astronauts on the International Space Station might soon be getting help from a swarm of snakebots, if Norwegian engineers get their way.
The State Department on Wednesday announced that it approved the sale of five P-8A Poseidon surveillance aircraft to Norway.
‘Norway will play an active and constructive role in the UN Peacebuilding Commission. We will use our experience in the areas of conflict prevention, mediation and peacebuilding to strengthen the UN’s work to promote peace and development,’ said Minister of Foreign Affairs Børge Brende.
The World Bank is stepping up its fight against poverty. From July 2017 to June 2020, Norway will provide NOK 2.7 billion to the World Bank’s Fund for the Poorest, the International Development Association (IDA).
The man overseeing energy policy in western Europe’s biggest oil-producing nation says the worst downturn in the history of Norway’s offshore industry appears to have bottomed out as Opec’s historic deal continues to reverberate across the globe.
A Norwegian missile designed for the F-35 has performed a fight test in the United States.
Norwegian Prime Minister Erna Solberg on Tuesday reshuffled her three-year-old government, replacing three ministers, ahead of next year’s general elections.